Suffolk County police say Wilguens Mentor falsely claimed burglars got into his store, Fly Forever Sneakers, in Wheatley Heights on October 31.
He allegedly reported that more than $60,000 in merchandise had been stolen.
Police say he planned to file a false claim with his insurance company.
Mentor is charged with second-degree attempted insurance fraud and third-degree falsely reporting an incident.
Get Eyewitness News Delivered